Should I Talk To The Insurance Company After A Car Accident?

The answer to this question is—yes, you should talk to your insurance company after a car accident—and—no, you shouldn’t talk to the other driver’s insurer. Even if it’s clear that the other party was deemed at-fault for the car accident, it’s best to engage your car accident attorney to speak with the other insurance company.

After a car accident, an agent from the at-fault driver’s insurer may call you. If you decide to speak with the agent, be very careful. Don’t provide any information to the other driver’s insurer.

You Aren’t Required to Speak with the At-Fault Driver’s Insurer

The law doesn’t require you to converse with the other driver’s insurer or any of its agents:

  • Don’t speak with the insurer if there’s a possibility that you, a passenger, or even the other driver will make a claim for a serious personal injury.
  • Don’t speak with the other insurance company if you’ve retained a car accident attorney (or if your insurer’s adjuster can address the other insurer’s questions).

When Should You Speak with the Other Insurer?

Rarely, you might want to speak with the other insurer:

  • If the at-fault driver lied to or refused to provide you with his or her insurer
  • If the at-fault driver is unaware of your vehicle damage or accident car injuries

However, it’s still better for your car accident attorney to have these discussions with the other insurer. Unless you’re involved in a minor accident, don’t risk a possible miscommunication with the at-fault driver’s insurance company.

If You Must Speak with the Other Insurance Company

Remember that the other insurance company’s goals are in direct opposition to your own. The at-fault insurer wants to pay you as little as possible to settle the potential claim. It doesn’t have your best interests in mind:

  • The at-fault driver’s insurance company is searching for evidence to blame you for the accident (or argue that you were partially at-fault for the accident)
  • The other insurance company’s attorneys will argue that your injuries or damages are either non-existent or extremely minor

Even if you feel relatively fine after a car accident, recognize that some injuries might not appear right away. A minor injury might evolve into a more serious condition. That’s why it’s important to get immediate medical attention after a car accident. Get regular medical attention to document your case progression.

Anything You Tell the Other Insurance Company Can Affect the Value of Your Claim

Again, it’s best to avoid speaking to the other insurer at all. Ask your car accident attorney to communicate with the other insurance company.

What you say can—and will—be used by the other insurer to refuse your claim or reduce the payout.

Never Volunteer Information

If you’re surprised by a phone call from the other insurer, just say no. If for some reason you’re speaking with the other insurer, ask for the agent to record your statement.

Better yet, contact your lawyer and ask him or her about the next steps. Don’t allow the other insurance company to lock you into making a written or recorded statement regarding the events, property damages, or injuries.

Don’t Speculate

Never attempt to speculate or guess about what caused the accident. It’s okay to speak with your own insurance company about anything but, if you don’t know the answer to a question, say you don’t know.

Engage Your Car Accident Lawyer

Let’s imagine you need to provide information requested by the other insurance company. Even if it’s objective information, such as 1) when the accident happened, 2) where the accident happened, 3) witness names, or 4) police officer/police report information.

It’s okay to ask your insurance adjuster to contact the other insurance company to provide this information.

If the other insurer needs information beyond the basics, get assistance from your car accident lawyer. She can prevent you from unknowingly providing the wrong information—or more information than you should provide.

Contact an Experienced Birmingham Car Accident Lawyer

Generally speaking, don’t discuss anything with the other insurance company. Don’t discuss who’s at fault, damages, or the seriousness of your injuries. Don’t speak with the at-fault driver’s insurer without your own legal representative.

Contact the Birmingham car accident lawyers at Salter Ferguson, LLC at 205-408-4357 to schedule an initial case evaluation now.

The articles on this blog are for informative purposes only and are no substitute for legal advice or an attorney/client relationship. If you are seeking legal advice, please contact our law firm directly.

Personal Injury

Personal injury laws pertain to injuries caused by another's negligence. Our legal team has more than 30 years of combined experience and a long track record of success handling personal injury cases. Over the years, our attorneys have won billions of dollars in financial compensation for injury victims.

Learn More

Mass Torts

A mass tort is when a group of people are harmed in a similar manner by a negligent or wrongful act. A mass tort claim allows an entire group of similarly injured people to seek financial compensation as a group in the civil court system, even though the specific circumstances of their cases may differ.

Learn More

What Sets

Salter Ferguson Apart


    Karen Salter is a registered nurse, and a former hospital manager. Her daughter, Carmen Ferguson, is a former insurance adjuster. Together, we have more than 30 years of legal experience to put to work on your case.

  • Professional & Personal Service

    We provide our injured clients with the personal service that they deserve. We keep you informed of developments in your case, answer your questions and return your calls and emails promptly. You will never be just another case at Salter Ferguson, LLC.

  • A Reputation for Excellence

    Salter Ferguson, LLC is Alabama-based but nationally recognized. Over the years we have won millions of dollars in financial compensation for injury victims. We have the skills and experience to achieve positive outcomes in challenging cases, yet we treat every client as if they were a member of our family.

Salter Ferguson Awards